Mr. Harish Trivedi,
I read your article “THE NEW UNTOUCHABILITY (IRONICALLY,
AMBEDKAR’S SUPPORTERS NOW PRONOUNCE HIM BEYOND THE) in The Times of India daily
newspaper on dated 26.05.2012.
After reading the whole article I noticed that this is one
more criticism which is being made on Dr.B.R.Ambedkar (THE FATHER OF INDIAN
CONSTITUTION). The allegations and criticism made by you adds one more childish
try to the same chapter. The criticism
made by you is not new to hear/read as many of your counterparts have tried to
do the same thing in the recent past since 1951.
Writing a constitution of any nation is not an easy
task. It becomes more difficult when we
think of India where hundreds of castes, races, religions, traditions, beliefs,
and customs are prevailing. Therefore it
needs Top Class mastery over the World Constitutions, Top Class Political
Knowledge and brilliance, Top class Philosopher who can study the past, analyze
the present and could foresee the future, it needs great knowledge of
difference civilizations, society and culture and also the legal knowledge
command, in depth knowledge of world history, Democracy, Anarchy, Imperialism
etc., and the knowledge of different administrations and its branches. Constitution can be made only by such person
who has in depth knowledge of Law and Social System of the countries. It becomes more difficult when it comes to
India wherein the larger section of people lived in thousand years in slavery,
experienced several atrocities. After
being ruled by Britishers for more than 150 years I feel it’s a miracle to
write the constitution of India. And
that miracle could become possible only because of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar.
It is well known that the Indian society has never digested
the fact that the greatest constitution has been written by AN
UNTOUCHABLE. Therefore it is evident
that time and again Dr.B.R.Ambedkar’s role in writing constitution is a subject
of serious criticism.
Mussolini says “if untruth is said hundred times people
start accepting the untruth as truth”.
The given example suits in the Indian context. It has been seen for 64 years now, every
small or big so called writer and intellectual (including the masses who are
least aware of constitution) criticizes Dr.B.R.Ambedkar for writing such
constitution and also deny that he is the father of Indian constitution. It is
natural that their stomach pain with the fact that the constitution is been
written by an untouchable. Right from Valmiki Choudhary to Arun Shourie, and
Vallab Bhai panth to Mr.L.K.Advani, each of them and many others criticized the
Indian Constitution and Dr.B.R Ambedakar’s role as the father of the
Constitution.
In the same line Mr.Harish Trivedi tried to through one more
stone on the great constitution and Dr.B.R.Ambedkar in his article published in
The Times of India on 26th November 2012. It seems to me that this
is a childish try to become famous. The following is the extract and my answer
on his criticism…
PARA 1:- He mentioned that the cartoon would have not caused much
offence had it been on any other national leaders or add other leaders too, it
is well known by the whole world that the Indian constitution has been written
by none other than Dr.B.R.Ambedkar.
Hence it is natural that his followers would not accept any criticism against
the father of the Indian constitution. Arun Shourie also tried few years back
by omitting his anger on Dr.B.R.Ambedkar and his followers by saying that “the
followers of Ambedkar seems to be fool as they rever Indian constitution as
their religious text and Ambedkar as a God. In the same line of criticism as
you said “It is not about what was done, it is about who was supposed to have
done it” if you read the whole constitutional debates and history of making of
Indian constitution keenly, you would understand and realize what was true.
Reply:- I would like to
refer one incident of constitutional making. In his book “Constitution in
Making” Mr. B.N. Rao writes that He and a committee of few members travelled
all over the world for recommending B.N. Rao’s name for writing Indian
constitution. Later on the same
committee goes to England and meets Prof.Jennings, a renowned political science
philosopher. Prof. Jennings laughs at them
and says that “there is a person in your own country whom we refer several times. He is political science genius having
abundant knowledge and command on all the world constitutions and political
science, his name is DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR. Prof. Jennings further says that, “I
don’t understand why you people are travelling everywhere when there is already
a master of all world constitutions in your own country”. After being insulted
in the hands of Prof. Jennings, the said committee headed by Mr. B. N. Rau
returns to India and as a result we see Dr. B. R. Ambedkar in the Parliament
being elected from Bombay. (There is
a detailed history behind it)
PARA 2:- as you have raised a doubt on THE ROLE OF DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR
IN FRAMING THE CONSTITUTION…it is really very irresponsible statement by a
so-called professor like you to ask such a childish question. You could have referred the constitutional
history and commented on the role of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar in framing
constitution.
Apart from
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar the following members were there in the Drafting Committee.
1.
N.Gopal
swami Iyangar
2.
Alladi
Krishna Swami Iyangar
3.
Sayyed
Mohammad Sadulla,
4.
K.M.Munshi
5.
B.L.Mittra
6.
D.P.
Khaitan (T.T.Krishnamchary after the death of Khaitan in 1948.)
Dr. Rajendra Prasad was the President of Constituent Assembly.
Mr.Trivedi, though there were the above committee members in
the Drafting Committee, NOT EVEN A SINGLE PERSON WORKED FOR FRAMING UP THE
INDIAN CONSTITUTION. I would like to remind you few statements made by the
eminent personalities, they are as follows…
“There were 7 members
appointed in the Constitutional Assemble, One of them resigned, whose place was
empty all the time, one person died and that place was also empty, one member
used to lived in America, ultimately his place also remained empty, one member
was busy with his political duties and could not spare time in the Assembly,
one or two people were out of Delhi hence it was impossible for them to adjust
in Delhi’s cold weather. Ultimately the
whole responsibility of framing of constitution shouldered on Dr.Ambedkar. We
all are obliged and grateful to Dr.Ambedkar, who could complete the tough task
of drafting the constitution alone.
Therefore his work is truly appreciable.
(Mr.T.T.Krishnamchari in Constitutional Assemble Debate,
Vol.7.page.231)
“I would not accept that Dr.Ambedkar’s work of making Indian
Constitution is like Hercules, because that is also an unequal comparison
altogether” –
(R.V.Dhulekar C and D Vol.11.)
“I would say that Dr.Ambedkar’s role in making constitution
is very important. No other member have
worked so hard, taking so much pain and strain with utmost care that has been
taken by Dr.Ambedkar (Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru)
“Dr.Ambedkar is not only the Father of Indian Constitution
but also The Mother…. (Dr.K.V.Rao)
Lastly the president of the Drafting Committee also praised
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar saying that “if we have taken any correct decision sitting on
this chair that must be to elect Dr.B.R.Ambedkar as the Chairman of Drafting
Committee.” It is well proven by the above said statements on the contribution
of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar for making the Indian Constitution. I hope the above given
reference are enough to show the role or Dr.B.R.Ambedkar in framing Indian
Constitution. The above statements are
of those national leaders whom everyone reveres with utmost respect. If we deny
these statements then it means we don’t accept the above names and do not
respect their statements. I hope that I don’t need other references to show you
furthermore the role of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar in making Indian constitution. If you are ready we can have a detailed
debate/discussion on any place mentioned by you at any given time. I am ready
to come to your place for any constitutional debate.
Next doubt raised by you i.e. THE CONSTITUTION DID TAKE A
LONG TIME TO FRAME. Again I would like
you to refer the same constitutional history wherein you can find the actual
time taken for writing the Indian constitution.
The constituent Assemble came into being in November, 1946. Its members
were elected in July, 1946. Out of 296 seats of British India, the Congress
captured 211 seats and the Muslim League 73 seats. The rest were not filled up.
The constituent Assemble met for the first time in New Delhi on December 9,
1946. The Muslim League refused to
participate in its deliberations. In spite of this, the Assembly made a
substantial progress. The objective
resolution was passed on January 22, 1947, which later became the Preamble of
the Constitution.
As a result of Partition under the PLAN OF JUNE 3, 1947, a
separate Constitution Assembly was set up for Pakistan on July 16, 1947. The representatives of Bengal, Punjab, Sind,
North Western Frontier Province, Baluchistan and the Sylhet district of Assam (which
had joined Pakistan by a referendum) ceased to be members of the Assembly of
India (which was constituted in 1946) and
there was a fresh election in the new Provinces of West Bengal and East
Punjab. In the result, when the
Constituent Assemble reassembled on the 31st October, 1947(after
Independence) the membership of the House was reduced to 299.
The Constituent Assemble appointed a Drafting Committee on
29th August, 1947 under the Chairmanship of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar.
When the drafting committee began its work the problem of
federation with the Native States had ceased to exist, as the Native States
which acceded to India merged in India
(after the few suggestion given by Dr.B.R.Ambedakar to Vallab bhai Panth). Now
the point to be noted is the critics must observe the time which was wasted
during the above said period. Even
though we could see that our constitution came in force only in 2years 11
months and 18 days. It is totally
illogical on part of the writer to say that the constitution has taken long
time in to frame.
The “Draft Constitution” prepared by the Drafting Committee
under the Chairmanship of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar was published in January, 1948. The people of India were given 8 months to discuss the draft and
propose amendments. As many as 7,635 amendments were proposed and 2,473 were actually
discussed. These all amendments were
checked and studied by Dr.B.R.Ambedkar alone during the making and this has
been accepted by the whole constituent assembly. If we compare the duration of writing the
other world constitutions and the Indian constitution (having 395 Articles, 8 Schedules and several
parts) it is difficult task to complete writing such a vast constitution in
the given spare of time i.e 2 years 11 months and 18 days.( I would suggest you
to refer the other world constitution and the actual time in writing them). But
unfortunately rather praising for the less time taken by Dr.B.R.Ambedkar in
writing constitution we feel honored to criticize him for delaying in framing
up constitution.
It is a clear sign of degrading the great constitution and
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar alleging that he had taken a long time to write the
constitution. And even if we say that it
has taken a long time to prepare the constitution then the blame should be
taken by the then national leader who always obstructed Dr.B.R.Ambedkar in
drafting the constitution.
PARA 3:- the next criticism made by you ie. AMBEDKAR WAS DECIDEDLY
NOT THE ‘AUTHOR’ OF OUR CONSTITION…this is also not a new criticism being made
on Dr.B.R.Ambedkar. it has become a
tradition for those who deny the fact that Dr.B.R.Ambedkar is the only father
of the constitution, and Mr.Trivedi’s criticism is also in the same line. I
have already given enough examples above to prove that Dr.B.R.Ambedkar is the
only father of the Indian constitution.
To strengthen my argument, I would mention an anonymous statement which
reads as “I have seen only two persons working hard day and night in the
constitution making and they are Dr.B.R.Ambedkar and his Dog Tobby”.
Mr.Trivedi, according to you Dr.B.R.Ambedkar is not single
author of the constitution and there are many other people who contributed in
the making of constitution. I would like
to ask you a question…will you give
credit in constructing your house to the Engineer or those people who brought
the Raw-Material for constructing your house..? According to you who constructed the house..!
The Engineer...or…., the labors who brought the Raw-Materials..? if you give the whole credit to the workers
who brought the raw material for constructing the house, then as per one of my
reference given above, THE DOG “TOBBY”
MUST BE GIVEN HIS DUE CREDIT FOR NOT SLEEPING WHOLE NIGHT DURING THE
CONSTITUTION MAKING…!why does his contribution should be denied? Isn’t it..!
It is said that Mr.B.N.Rao prepared a draft constitution and
gave it to Dr.B.R.Ambedkar. Basing on
the information given by him in the draft, Dr.Ambedakar could write the
constitution. Mr.Trivedi, I would
suggest you to read the constitutional debates once again and the words of
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar. You would notice that Dr.Ambedkar denied most of the
provisions given by Mr.B.N.Rao in his draft. You could also observe that Mr.B.N
Rao was never present in the Assemble in debates because he was totally upset
by the election of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar as the Chairman of Drafting Committee. Later
on he left to Hegue country and lived his rest of life there itself.
As you said that “the constitution is a collaborative
document, of which each member of a constituent assemble could equally be
called an author.” I already gave exact
words of Mr.T.T.Krishnamchary on the role played by other committee
members. Not even a single committee
member put up their efforts in writing the constitution. On which base anyone can claim to be the
author of constitution without giving his time and effort..? if this is so then
as I said The Dog “ Tobby” would also be given his credit..! isn’t it?
PARA 4:- as claimed by you and many other critics that Dr.Ambedkar
prepared the constitution on the “draft already been prepared on the basis of
the reposts of various committees comprising numerous members of the constituent
assembly. These reports were then compiled and collated by the secretariat of
the assembly led by SN Mukherjee, who was the chief draftsman, and by an expert
‘Constitutional Advisor’ named BN Rau.”
Reply:- Mr.Trivedi, The Constituent Assemble met in November,
1948 to consider the provisions of the Draft, clause by clause, After several
sessions in consideration of the clauses, second reading was completed by 17th
October, 1949. The Constituent Assembly
again sat on 14th November 1949.
The Constituent Assembly held 11 Sessions. The Draft Constitution was considered for 114
days. As many as 7,635 amendments were
proposed and 2,473 were actually discussed. Dr.B.R.Ambedkar referred all the
amendments which came to him, discussed all of them in the Assemble and
proposed only the above said issues in the Assembly. I could hardly see during
all this process there is any role of Mr.SN Mukherjee or BN Rau in the
assemble, in fact when Mr.BN Rao understood that he will not be given any place
in the Constituent Assembly, he left India forever and settled in Hegue, he never returned India thereafter. So it is baseless in saying that BN Rau
contributed during the assembly discussion.( Read Constitution In Making – B.N
Rau) In relation to the Constitutional Advisory Committee, the committee itself
took advises from Dr.B.R.Ambedkar when the question of unification of various
institutions(Native States) came up. Hence it is totally baseless to claim that
the draft was already prepared and Dr.Ambedkar used the same draft in writing
the constitution and even the role of Advisory Committee.
Its to bring into your notice that Dr.Ambedkar has been
acknowledged by whole world as the father of Indian Constitution. Hungary (a country) has schools, collages and
universities in the name of Dr.Ambedkar, even The President of U.S.A. Mr.Barack
Obama acknowledged Dr.Ambedkar as the father of Indian Constitution. In “The
Principles of Social And Political Theory” written by Prof.Arnest Walker, he
has dedicated his book to the Preamble of Indian Constitution. It is accepted by the whole world that
Dr.Ambedkar’s political and Constitutional vision is on par with the world
philosophers, his vision and wisdom to foresee the future Is unmatched in all
over the world and therefore whole world rever him as a constitutional father
and a philosophical mastermind, who has given this world the Masterpiece Gem of
Parliamentarian Democracy in the form of Indian Constitution.
It is a sign of every great personality that they don’t take
credit of their work. They always give
credit to others. Dr.B.R.Ambedkar did
the same thing by acknowledging every member of the committee for making up the
constitution. It was his big heart that
he acknowledged every member, but it is sad and unfortunate that the Indian
society and the so-called educated people like you doesn’t acknowledge nor be
thankful to Dr.B.R.Ambedakr for his great work.
Rather people feel great honor by criticizing the constitution and its
father Dr.B.R.Ambedakar.
To comment on the last Paragraph of your article where you
mentioned that “there is an Ambedkar who contributed to our Constitution, and
there is another Ambedkar who is the father figure of dalit power. In our present political scenario, because
the latter is sacrosanct, therefore the former cannot be touched with a
bargepole either. Thus, ironically,
Ambedkar is now again ‘untouchable’…agreeing with your comments that there are
two Ambedakar, one contributed to our constitution and one is the father figure
of dalits. There is one more Ambedkar…
rising in the world scenario which is not been acknowledged by the poor Indian
intellectuals. The whole world is now studying
Dr.Ambedkar as a philosopher, as an emancipator of crores of backward classes
of India, who rose against the tyranny of brahmnical atrocities and liberated
his people from the mental slavery, who alone rose against the thousand old
mental and physical slavery and gave millions of people a new era of Liberty,
Equality Fraternity and Justice. The
whole world is studying and following his contribution for Humanitarian
Principles which have universal appeal.
That’s the reason why Columbia University honored Dr.B.R.Ambedkar as THE
MOST REMARKABLE COLUMBIAN and placed him among the TOP 4 PEOPLE WHO CONTRIBUTED
IN THE MAKING OF UNIVERSE. (Refer book THE
MAKERS OF UNIVERSE.)
“ Hallat ke Kadmo pe kalander nahi jhukata, tute bhi taraa
vo zamin pe nahi girta,
Milti hai bade shouk se samander me dariya, lekin kabhi
samander dariya me nahi milta…”
Regards…
Adv Mahendra Jadhav (LLM)
Hyderabad.
Ph: 08008754848
Dr.AMBEDKAR (1891-1956)
ReplyDeleteB.A., M.A., M.Sc., D.Sc., Ph.D., L.L.D., D.Litt., Barrister-at-Law
B.A.(Bombay University) Bachelor of Arts,
MA.(Columbia university) Master Of Arts,
M.Sc.( London School of Economics) Master Of Science,
Ph.D. (Columbia University) Doctor of philosophy ,
D.Sc.( London School of Economics) Doctor of Science ,
L.L.D.(Columbia University) Doctor of Laws ,
D.Litt.( Osmania University) Doctor of Literature,
Barrister-at-Law (Gray's Inn, London) law qualification for a lawyer to practice law in royal court of England.
Sir/Mam,please help me to prove that He was The most Educated Indian of his time And/Or He was the most educated person of his time on planet earth.
Personal collection of books:9000 (excluding the collection collection of books, which were lost when the ship on which they were dispatched was torpedoed and sunk by a German submarine)
(with proficiency in Marathi, Hindi, English, Sanskrit, Persian, German, Pali. Also basic French.
the only minister in India to Resign as a law minister when Hindu code Bill designed to get equal rights to Women could not passed by nehru government.
Women to have right to property and Maternity Leave.
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar was:-
An Indian Jurist A Political Leader
A Buddhist Activist An Advanced Thinker
A Philosopher An Anthropologist
A Historian An Orator
A prolific writer An Economist
A great scholar An Educationist
At Columbia: coursework: During Ambedkar's time at Columbia he would sit for hours studying in *Low Library*; the rotunda then housed the main reading room. His *coursework* during his three years (including summers) at Columbia consisted of: 29 courses in economics, 11 in history, 6 in sociology, 5 in philosophy, 4 in anthropology, 3 in politics, and 1 each in elementary French and German. (Source: Office of the Registrar, Columbia University.)
let us start a tradition of mentioning educational qualification of Dr.Ambedkar below every statue, below every photo/pamphlet, in articles, book titles and cover pages, whenever there is first reference in newspapers, discussions, meetings and even in debates, citations, politics, economics, history, humanity, social circles
• Elementary Education, 1902 Satara, Maharashtra
• Matriculation, 1907, Elphinstone High School, Bombay Persian etc.,
• Inter 1909,Elphinstone College,Bombay Persian and English
• B.A, 1912 Jan, Elphinstone College, Bombay, University of Bombay, Economics & Political Science
• M.A 2-6-1915 Faculty of Political Science, Columbia University, New York, Main-Economics
Ancillaries-Sociology, History Philosophy, Anthropology, Politics
• Ph.D 1917 Faculty of Political Science, Columbia University, New York, ‘The National Divident of India – A Historical and Analytical Study’
• M.Sc 1921 June London School of Economics, London ‘Provincial Decentralization of Imperial Finance in British India’
• Barrister-at- Law 30-9-1920 Gray’s Inn, London Law
D.Sc 1923 Nov London School of Economics, London ‘The Problem of the Rupee – Its origin and its solution’ was accepted for the degree of D.Sc. (Economics).
• L.L.D (Honoris Causa) 5-6-1952 Columbia University, New York For HIS achievements, Leadership and authoring the constitution of India
• D.Litt (Honoris Causa) 12-1-1953 Osmania University, Hyderabad For HIS achievements, Leadership and writing the constitution of India
all this education achieved before 1954 .
Barack Obama (US President) also paid tribute to Dr. Ambedkar in Indian Assembly.
he was a life time student and mastered in Economics, Law, Democracy, Philosophy, History, International Relations, Anthropology, Religious Study, Music, Literature and so on….
Mohandas Gandhi Vs Dr.Ambedkar
ReplyDeleteDear All, Many times People compare Mohandas Gandhi With Dr.Ambedkar.
1)Mohandas Gandhi (Mahatma is not a legal term and it is given by party)
1)Chief Architect of Indian Constitution Dr.Ambedkar (please notice the abbreviation Dr.)
2)Mohandas Gandhi Bar-at-Law
2)Dr.Ambedkar B.A.,M.A.,M.Sc.,D.Sc.,Ph.D.,L.L.D.,D.Litt.,Barrister-at-Law.
B.A.(Bombay University) Bachelor of Arts,
MA.(Columbia university) Master Of Arts,
M.Sc.( London School of Economics) Master Of Science,
Ph.D. (Columbia University) Doctor of philosophy ,
D.Sc.( London School of Economics) Doctor of Science ,
L.L.D.(Columbia University) Doctor of Laws ,
D.Litt.( Osmania University) Doctor of Literature,
Barrister-at-Law (Gray's Inn, London) law qualification for a lawyer to practice law in royal court of England.
1) Gandhi was from rich modhi baniya community, Ambedkar from poor mahar ati shudra community.
2) Gandhi took 10 minutes to reach his fathers dead body from his room to his fathers room, Ambedkar took 20 hrs to reach his dying father from Baroda to Mumbai.
4) Gandhi was Matric barrister (No Degree, like diploma of today) while Ambedkar was Doctorate barrister (eight degrees).
5) Gandhi served as major in South African Army before practicing Law in SA, Ambedkar taught as professor in Sydneham College before practicing Law in Mumbai.
6) Gandhi worte “My experiments with truth”, Ambedkar’s writings are still being published in 28 volumes. They say 42 volumes will not be enough.
7) Gandhi had Birlas & Goenkas with him to give monetary support for his movement. Ambedkar had only Pawar & Naval Bhetna to give him loan for purchasing books.
8) Gandhi built ashram for khadi gram udyog, Ambedkar built house for keeping books and built colleges for spreading education,Knowledge
9) Gandhi practiced indriya control (as written in his bio), Ambedkar married second time with Doctor for degrading health reason.
10) Gandhi did not advocate reservation for OBC, Ambedkar resigned from ministry for women’s rights
Is there any Minister in India who had resigned for women’s rights?.
11) Gandhi is not responsible for partition . Tilak and Jinah had passed this resolution in 1917 itself. Ambedkar did not divide India into caste , it is done through texts like Manusmriti, Purush Sukta, Tatriya Brahman etc.
12) Gandhi was killed by circumcisioned Nathuram Godse , Ambedkar died in sleep (debate).
13) Gandhi was fond of spinning cotton, Ambedkar was fond of reading Books.
14) Gandhi claimed to be leader of harijans and showed 2 telegrams in 2nd round table conference, Ambedkar did not claim to be leader of harijans but showed thousand telegrams in the same meeting.
15) Gandhi refused to give equal human status to Shudras and advocated 4 varna (vertical) system, Ambedkar committed his life for equal human status to Shudras and asked Gandhi if he can give the same 4 varna (horizontal) system. Gandhi denied.
16) Gandhi described Shudras as harijans (Children of God) but did not describe upper caste as children of whom. Ambedkar said that calling Shudras as harijans means the same.Gandhi didn’t say “We are ALL children of god”.Instead he said “HARIJANS are childrens of god”. What about other people?
17) Gandhi could do all work with help of many prominent leaders and moneyed people, Ambedkar did all things single-handedly.
18) Gandhi never fought election. Ambedkar lost lok sabha election to 7th pass congress candidate But he won Rajya Sabha election from Jasor & Khulna dist of Bengal, and because of which these districts were given to bangle desh considering the prople of this places as defectors to congress.
19) Gandhi went on fast to death in Poona against empowerment of so called his harijans. Ambedkar in reluctance signed the Poona pact and saved his life.(That represent the love for Humanity He had not allowed even his biggest enemy to die)
20)Gandhi just spoken good things but Dr.Ambedkar thought great and enacted those thoughts into reality with different possible efforts, methods ,ways and means. So please there is no comparison
ReplyDeleteSir/Madam, browse on following website (The contents in the following link require years to understand fully.Because Its a written work of Dr.Ambedkar comprising 4795 pages (Can be a world record of that time) ) (otherwise copy and paste in browser window)
http://drambedkarbooks.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/selected-work-of-dr-b-r-ambedkar.pdf
some most imp links covering his contributions and myth of Mohandas Gandhi
http://dalitskerala.wordpress.com/2010/04/15/dr-b-r-ambedkar-%E2%80%9Cman-of-the-millennium%E2%80%9D/
http://www.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474977696310
http://hinduexistence.org/tag/mohandas-karamchand-gandhi-exposed/
http://islamreview.org/anwarshaikh/misc/Saints1.html
http://sikhfreedom.com/gandhi.html
http://psenthilraja.wordpress.com/gandhi-exposed/
http://sikhspectrum.com/2008/07/gandhi-under-cross-examination/
http://dalkhalsa.blogspot.in/2011/04/mahatma-gandhi-racist-and-bisexual.html
http://www.khalistan-affairs.com/wp/?p=771
http://mytake-charakan.blogspot.in/2009/03/advani-on-dr-ambedkar-masking-history.html
Respected Sir/Mam if you feel this info worth sharing the please help me to spread it.
VICTORY Be Happy !
Sir/Mam i requested Columbia University to mail me the rankings of "columbians ahead of time" but they didnt send me. IT WILL BE BETTER IF WE GET ACTUAL official RANKING FROM COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY AS A PROOF FIRST.
ONE CLICK DOWNLOAD OF ALL (52 PRESENTLY) 52 BOOKS OF Dr.Ambedkar. plz click following link (otherwise copy and paste in browser window)
http://drambedkarbooks.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/selected-work-of-dr-b-r-ambedkar.pdf
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._R._Ambedkar (Hindu code bill. and so many details)
http://www.mombu.com/culture/india/t-khushwant-singh-power-of-brahmanism-5464219.html
http://www.sikhreview.org/pdf/february2003/pdf-files/lihgter.pdf
http://dalitskerala.wordpress.com/2010/04/15/dr-b-r-ambedkar-%E2%80%9Cman-of-the-millennium%E2%80%9D/
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2172967/Indian-government-spends-700-000-buy-letters-prove-national-hero-Gandhi-gay.html?ITO=1490
Sir/Mam, If u feel this info worth to be spread then plz help me to spread it
one complete solution to all problems of sc/st/obc’s & minorities
ReplyDeleterespected sir/madam,
the biggest fear for a humans in this world is fear of death/severe punishment.
before freedom nobody could dare to do wrong things why?
because there was fear of immediate severe punishment (without any excuse, carelessness) by British authorities.
features of such punishments
1.punishment without any time pass (saved time)
2.severe punishment in proportion to severity of crime
3.strict laws and 100% implementation of those laws prevented crimes
because of above reasons no one could dare to commit crime at that time.
after freedom
1.if someone want to do something illegal he knows tahasildar/sub-inspector/session court will not take any action (they know superintendent of police/collector/district court will not terminate and punish them even if juniors don't perform their duty)
2.superintendent of police/collector know that chief minister/high court will not take any action (they know chief minister/high court will not terminate and punish them even if juniors don't perform their duty)
3.chief minister/high court know that governor will not take any action (they know governor will not terminate and punish them even if juniors don't perform their duty)
4.governor knows that cabinet minister/supreme court/prime minister will not take any action (they know cabinet minister/supreme court/prime minister will not terminate and punish them even if juniors don't perform their duty)
5.prime minister know that there is nobody above him to punish and terminate him on grounds of direct,indirect,visible,invisible,immediate,delayed,carelessness,incompetency,unsuitability,inefficiency, ineligibility, delay, corruption, loss (they know 125 crore Indians/ supreme court will not terminate, punish, slap, beat, throw stones on him or hang him if p.m. don't perform his duty because of 3 tier security (in absence of security prime minister/cabinet minister/chief minister/any minister cannot dare to move in india because he knows that as he/she is not performing his duty people may express their emotions with words and/or actions)
answer is simple p.m. dont have any fear of
1.losing job
2.no fear of immediate strict direct/indirect criminal action/no chance of severe punishment, capital punishment for direct, indirect, visible, invisible, immediate, delayed carelessness, incompetency, unsuitability, inefficiency, ineligibility ,delay, corruption, loss.
so mostly ministers/government officers don’t perform their duty and
they will not resign or they will not let other eligible people to perform it.
so they will simply stay at their designations till their retirement..
if some honest officer tries to perform his duty then all his corrupted senior/junior officers, neighbors , media, related/unrelated inhuman beings and all corrupted ministers will together hamper, oppose, trouble, suspend, terminate and may even kill him/his family members /relatives directly or indirectly (socially/economically/legally/spiritually /emotionally/ physically) in every possible visible and/or invisible ways.
then how can a honest officer dare to perform his duty against all corrupted senior/junior officers and surrounding?
i am not saying this to any specific P.M. or C.M.. (present or past). i am saying it in general applicable to every country/every government/every administration.
conclusion
ReplyDeleteif we get honest fearless intelligent dedicated well qualified suitable eligible prime minister and other similar central and state level ministers who can take strong actions, can sacrifice his job/life, blood, body, time, pleasures, money, happiness, sleep, hunger, thirst, energy, peace, wealth and even his entire life (the most precious thing of the humans) for our well secured/simplified future (future without struggle for food,water,education,liberty,equality,fraternity,,freedom,respect,justice). and will not compromise/care/tolerate/entertain anything/anybody/any action/any nonsense against welfare of human beings. for eradication of inhuman thoughts and inhuman people legally.
action should be immediate(without loss of precious time, money, energy (i have purposefully not mentioned life in this list as sometimes we may have to punish legally one negative person to save 100 innocent ones)), impactive, strict, energy efficient and should cost less money.
Complete History of India with Through religious and social Analysis and citations is http://www.skidmail.com/hindu/contents.htm
Hidden Secret of India Poverty with English Subtitles
Sir/Mam,copy following with quotes& paste in Youtube
"Unreported India - Broken People" 3 VIDS
"India Untouched - Darker side of India " 4 VIDS India's hidden secret for centuries. "Untouchability - Dignity for All ".
It took 4 Years to shoot and 25000 km Journey to Complete the Mission of finding TRUTH.
TRUE AIM OF HUMAN’S LIFE
ReplyDeleteTo Gain maximum pure knowledge And utilize it to the fullest for Welfare of Humanity (Those who really need it the most).
We should not waste out time, money, energy, knowledge, skills, authority (And all our Valuable resources) under the brand headlines/excuse of Entertainment, Enjoyment, Hobbies/Interests/ Habits, Picnic , Party ,”Just for change”, unnecessary celebrations/ festivals , “just for fun”, addictions of tobacco, alcohol ,Leisure, grief Relaxation, Property, time pass, hours of social networking, boyfriend/girlfriend. If we waste these resources then at last stage of life a disgraceful thought will come to our mind like this “Even though I had three times nutritious meals, pure drinking water to drink, good health without any physical/mental Disability ,adequate education, money, time, a home to live, family members to care/guide and assist, and all other resources of a prosperous human, BUT I HAVE NOT CONTRIBUTED TO THE WELFARE OF HUMANITY ANYWAY ,NOT THOUGHT ABOUT IT EVEN ONCE”
When our children and grand childrens will ask us
“Daddy/Mummy ,What you have done for this world so that it has become more peaceful ,more happy, more developed in true sense?
How you have contributed directly And indirectly to the development of humanity, integrity, liberty, equality, fraternity, society?”
How much is your share in all good things that are present today?
Definitely they will analyze our answers thoroughly with their small but more powerful and inquisitive mind! We will not be able to fool them surely.(Many times children’s curiosities will cross the barriers of age, wisdom and experience and they will ask us clever questions/cross questions naturally. And we will be speechless)
if we don’t have any answer then that will be the most embarrassing moment of our life and that too at last stage when there will not be any chance to recover the past mistake and many will be forced to criticize themselves in loneliness with tears.
Our Great ancestors said “this world is my home”, And thought. behaved , acted accordingly .Lived and died for the same purpose of welfare OF WORLD.
Today’s most of the people (some forcefully/knowingly/unknowingly) says “this home is my world” And think, behave and act accordingly. Live and die for the same purpose of welfare OF HOME.
Respected Elders And dear Brothers/Sisters,
human being means
1.pure by thoughts (which will leads to revolutionary actions/deeds)
2.pure by behavior (which will spread good thoughts)
3.pure by body (which will maintain good health to assist in above two accomplishments efficiently)
let us try to achieve these things together by sharing our time, money, energy, intelligence, skills, knowledge, all resources and opinions through communication, co-ordination, cooperation & mutual understanding for personal, educational, social, economical, scientific, spiritual & overall betterment, equity, development and welfare to fulfill dreams, expectations and aims of our parents, our great ancestors ( (which are not mentioned here as their count is a big number ) who scarified their blood, body, time, pleasures, money, happiness, sleep, hunger, thirst, family, energy, peace, wealth, empire, family members (remember hundreds of known/unknown/un-noticed true freedom fighters ,Social workers, reformers) and even their entire life (the most precious thing of the humans) for our well secured/simplified future (future with less struggle for simple food, pure water, shelter, peace, harmony, happiness, basic education, equality, freedom, respect, justice).
I believe if we unite and work together we can do /achieve/fight/challenge/overcome and win… anything and everything in this world.
our lakhs of brothers and sisters are still forced to live life of animals, (discriminated on the basis of their occupation, literacy/illiteracy, rural/urban, body colour , Gender, clothes, Mother tongue, state/country citizenship, North/South India, residential locality, Caste/Sub-caste/religion ,political parties workers,
beliefs/prejudices) in unhygienic, poor, unlivable conditions, because of some INHUMAN, politicians/government officers/ignorant society (mostly whose minds are programmed with racism/ inequality, thoughts, actions and rituals right from birth/childhood by most of media).
ReplyDeletethey need our guidance, resources, every type of possible help.
just imagine for a minute a life of an illiterate, poor, jobless boy/girl struggling for 2 time nutritious meals, clean drinking water, basic education ,simple clothes to cover the body, a simplest roof of polythin to protect from rain, sunlight, wind, cold. living life near a gutter full of mosquitoes… …. diseases … .. Without any proper care/guidance… … .. . And during all this sustaining/undergoing torture of so-called INHUMAN, politicians/government officers/ignorant society … .. .
this life will become/ is becoming hell for them… .. .(that’s why many will prefer to suicide forcefully by considering it as the quick, easiest, best, chip and complete solution. (actually these are indirect ,invisible and deliberately UN-NOTICED ,UNPUBLISHED,UNCOVERED brutal heinous murders))
dear brothers/sisters they need our helping hand in every aspect.. .. .
at least in providing them basic fundamental things that a human needs (nutritious food, drinking water, livable shelter, little money and knowledge to sustain and live life of a ordinary human and to face and overcome this brutal inhuman politicians/govt officers /ignorant society/ Anti social elements torture. ).
we are educated sons and daughters of our great ancestors who fought and sacrificed their lives for development of humanity.. let us unite and vow to use all of our combined/collective resources and every moment of our life to make them live a life of a human being. to make them feel and realize that they are also human. Sir/Mam If you feel (by study, analysis and discussion that ) this information is conveying the right aim then please help me to spread it .If every teacher in this world imprints this ideas right from KG/Primary school then surely this world will get revolutionized!!!
Your Student and Servant of humanity
Victory
India,