Friday, September 11, 2015

Indian Constitution and Educational Rights


Abstract: -
 
Indian Constitution and Education Rights is indeed a very important topic and 
it is the need of hour to understand the educational rights and how 
Indian Constitution speaks about imparting education to all sections of the 
society.  
 
Keyword: - Education, Constitution of India, Educational Rights, Violations, Illiteracy
 
 
Introduction:-
 
Many people get confused with the word "Education". According to some people "Education" is a degree, 
an academic title, which is the source of their identity, which helps in getting jobs and career high status.
However, according to me “Education” has different meaning. I divide it in two parts i.e. “Education” 
and “Literacy”! It is to be noted that being educated is different from being literate. Literacy can help us in 
getting jobs and settle in our career. It is helpful in raising the standard of living and creating a status in society.
But, “Education” helps us understand the difference between Truth and Untruth! Education gives us the sense of 
right and wrong!
 
Do we really feel that the current situation of education in the country helps us to discern between the truth and 
untruth? Does today’s education bestow impartial/unbiased education to all? Do we really think that today’s 
educational system and institutions are teaching comparative and scientific approach to the students to see the 
world? My answer to these questions is “Straight No..!”
 
I firmly believe that the current educational system has imposed the modern mental slavery on students. Higher the education, more the mental slave…More the education, greater the proud feeling… higher the education, highest the demands of dowry and patriarch feeling. Everything has become mechanical and commercial!
Discussion: -
 
Dr. B.R.Ambedakar has always seen education with a different perspective. According to him, education can
solve any problems of the country, but he was particular about what type of education should be given and to
which class of people. Explaining the importance of the education he says, [1]“Can education destroy caste? The answer is ‘Yes’ as well as ‘No’. If education is given as it is to-day, education can have no effect on caste. It will remain as it will be. The glaring example of it is the Brahmin Caste. Cent percent of it is educated, nay; majority of it is highly educated. Yet not one Brahmin has shown himself to be against caste. In fact an educated person belonging to the higher caste is more interested after his education to retain the Caste System than when he was not educated. For education gives him an additional interest in the retention of the Caste System namely by opening additional opportunity of getting a bigger job. From this point of view, education is not helpful as means to dissolve caste. So far is the negative side of education. But education may be solvent if it is applied to the lower strata of the Indian Society. It would raise their spirit of rebellion. In their present state of ignorance they are the supporters of the Caste System. Once their eyes are opened they will be ready to fight the Caste System.”
 
The point to be understood from the above statement of Dr.B.R.Ambedkar is, education can be very instrumental in annihilation of caste system, untouchability and inequality provided the education is given to the suppressed classes. Because educated youngsters will revolt against injustice and inequality, education will help them to inspire for the same. That’s the reason why Dr.Ambedakar promulgated several articles for education such as Art.15, 21A,28,30,38,39,41,45,46,47  in the Indian Constitution to ensure that quality education been given to every citizen of this country irrespective of their  Caste, Class, Race, Religion, Gender and Place of Birth.  But unfortunately at one side we see the total corporatization of education system where Article 21A and Article 42 speaks about Free and Compulsory Education until the age of 14 years, and at the other hand the government is less interested in providing necessary infrastructure and developments to the government schools. The detoriated conditions of government schools are so pathetic that several schools are at the door steps of closing down. The quality of education in the government schools is so degraded that the students can’t even think of competing with the corporate schools.
Article 15 of the Indian Constitutions speaks about Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth[2]. In several instances in the recent past we have seen that the kids from low castes and Muslim families have been denied for sitting in the school classrooms and learn along with the other student. Despite constitutional right, the ignorance toward the fundamental rights speaks about the intentions of few fundamentalists who don’t want to abolish inequality on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place or birth.
Article 21A provides Right to education[3]. This article was Inserted by the 86th Amendment in December, 2002 and passed by the Parliament in July, 2009. The provisions of the Act came into force from 1st April, 2010. Earlier this right was enshrined in Art.45 of the Constitution under Directive Principles of State Policies. But seeing the non implementation of the article and absence of larger sections of kids being far from education, an amendment being made in Art.21A for Right to Education. After this amendment providing education has been made a fundamental right and no one shall be kept away from basic educations. 
Article 30 gives Right to minorities to establish and administer educational institutions on their own so that they can educate themselves in their own institutions[4]. The state has to provide necessary funds and assistance for establishing educational institutions of the minorities. Article 38 of Part IV of Directive Principles of State Policies talks about the State to secure a social order for the promotion of welfare of the people. The promotion of welfare of people lies in quality education, health and sanitation. The constitution of India directs the state to take necessary steps to do so. But unfortunately during the past 65 years of independence the social, economical and educational conditions of the people are considerable low compared to the other countries.
Article 39 speaks about Certain principles of policy to be followed by the State and direct its policy towards securing adequate means of livelihood, equal pay for equal work, and care of health and strength of the workers, men and women etc.[5] similarly Art.41 directs the state to take steps within its limit to make effective provisions for securing the right to work, to education and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement and in any other cases of undeserved wants.[6]
Article 45 originally mandates the state to provide free and compulsory education to children between the age of sex and fourteen years. But until the 86th Amendment in 2002[7], this provision was highly been neglected by the state governments. Seeing this parliament amendment the constitution in 2002. It has been converted into a fundamental right under Art.21A. Now, right to education is a fundamental right and the citizens can go to court for violation of this right.
 I firmly believe that the degraded condition of the educational system especially in the government schools is the part of serious conspiracy. It is to be noted that more than 70% of the population lives in the urban, sub-urban and villages. Most of them belong to poor families their kids studies in government schools. The system understands well that, if quality education is been given to these classes of people, they will certainly revolt and raise voice against injustice, inequality and other social issues. 
The latest Education for All Global Monitoring Report (GMR) released worldwide by the UNESCO acknowledges the headway made by India in improving access to education but the country’s population of illiterate adults has been identified as the drag factor. India currently has the largest population of illiterate adults in the world with 287 million. This is 37 per cent of the global total. While India’s literacy rate rose from 48 per cent in 1991 to 63 per cent in 2006, “population growth cancelled the gains so there was no change in the number of illiterate adults,” the report stated[8]. According to the report, India, despite spending a considerable amount on education, has reduced its expenditure on education from 13 per cent of the entire government budget in 1999 to 10 per cent in 2010.
In India, 4% of our children never start school. 58% don’t complete primary schools. And 90% don’t complete school. If we believe in UNESCO’s report only 10% kids of the total population completes their college education. We have to understand that the percentage of poor kids among college going is trivial![9]
According to the CIA World Fact book, almost 75% of the world's 775 million illiterate adults are concentrated in ten countries (in descending order: India where almost 30 million young women are illiterate) China, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nigeria, Ethiopia, Egypt, Brazil, Indonesia, and the Democratic Republic of Congo).[10]The point to be noted here is if we compare the total population of the other eight countries, we see that their geographical areas are equal to India’s few states, but still India is among the highest illiterate population, how shameful ! 
The country which was famous for world known universities such as Nalanda, Takshashila, Vikramshila, Odantapuri, where thousands of foreigners used to come and took education in Indian Universities, we were the ones who gifted knowledge and education to the whole world..! But sadly in the current conditions we are considered among the highest illiterate countries of the world! The rulers of this great nations must introspect on what they have given to its citizens except Poverty, inequality fanaticism and injustice....!
Due to the lack of quality education and poor conditions of government schools in sub-Urban areas and villages, over 60 Million children are forced into child labor in India. We, being an IT giant and the world's second-fastest growing major economy, has millions of child labors all under 14 years of age, some as young as 4 or 5, and all toiling hard just to get a square meal to keep body and soul from parting company. [11]Child labor is a dagger through India's soul. The country has the dubious distinction of being home to the largest child labor force in the world, with an estimated 30% of the world's working kids living here. You find children being exploited in restaurants, silk industry, carpet weaving, firecracker units, etc. 80% of child laborers reside in rural India, where they are forced to work in agricultural activities such as fanning, livestock rearing, forestry and fisheries. Reports say that there are more children under the age of 14 in India than the entire population of the United States. And children under 14 years of age account for about 4% of the total labor force in the country. Of these children, nine out of every ten work in their own rural family settings. Two out of every three working children are physically abused. Over 50% children were being subjected to one or the other form of physical abuse. 50.2% children worked seven days a week, 53.22% children reported having faced one or more forms of sexual abuse. 21.90% child respondents reported facing severe forms of sexual abuse and 50.76% other forms of sexual abuse.
Every second child reported facing emotional abuse. The Indian Constitution says that child labor is a wrong practice and standards should be set by law to eliminate it. The Child Labor Act of 1986 implemented by the government of India makes child labor illegal in many regions and sets the minimum age of employment at 14 years.[12]
After its independence from colonial rule, India has passed a number of constitutional protections and laws on child labor. The Constitution of India in the Fundamental Rights and the Directive of State Policy prohibits child labor below the age of 14 years in any factory or mine or castle or engaged in any other hazardous employment (Article 24). [13]The constitution also envisioned that India shall, by 1960, provide infrastructure and resources for free and compulsory education to all children of the age six to 14 years. (Article 21-A and Article 45).
We have to understand that the maximum population among the illiterate kids and
child labors dalit and Muslims children holds the highest percentage is a naked
truth! All these children don’t have proper learning, no hope, neither future nor appropriate guidance to 
excel in life. Nothing has changed during the past 65 years of independence and despite having the greatest 
constitution of the world. The children’s are forced into modern slavery to live an undignified life without any
 future!

Conclusion: -
I personally feel that we need to understand one thing very aptly ie we can’t expect anything from the system. The governments are not cordial towards the poors and have nots ! The governments are pro corporates ! And to expect something from such corporatized government would a big mistake on our part. Because, not the only educational system but also Healthcare, Medicine, Science, Politics, Industries, Service Sectors and all other areas , they have kept in their pocket . We can see with our naked eyes that their intention is to have all the powers in their pockets and to impose sanctions and slavery on everyone else!
All this while walking in front of our eyes, the big question lies upon us to introspect and question our self what we can do to overcome these problems? Greater question is can we challenge this powerful system! Can we give an alternative to this nation! Can we change the ongoing degradation of education system? The answer lies in Yes and No both!  If we understand our duties and responsibilities towards the society and country as a whole, then certainly we can give an alternative. But, if we run away from our responsibilities giving excuses of our wife, kids, family, jobs then there would be no meaning to our life.  The choice is totally ours…!

In our society, maximum numbers of employees are teachers. Most of them have completed their graduation, D.Ed, B.Ed and teaching in various schools, colleges, institutions and universities. And therefore I feel, the teaching class can play a vital role in nation development. We all know the degraded conditions of the schools and colleges. We also know that, it is highly impossible to compete with the world studying in such degraded schools and colleges. We cannot expect any students who belong to poor family and taking education in government schools and colleges that he will compete with corporate students and excel himself in the era of globalization. The biggest question lies before us to how we can change these precarious conditions.
I feel, the teachers should come forward and take up the responsibilities. They should start free classes in the fields of Competitive education, Technical and Academic Guidance and all such areas which can help a student to learn nuances of different fields and he could be able to compete with the world. If all the teachers who have sense of injustice and equality initiate this process on war foot, then I firmly believe that we can create a generation who will serve this country and society with utmost honesty and sincerity. And we have to do it otherwise we will be answerable to the coming generations..!

References:
1.      What Are The Prospects of Democracy In India – Dr.B.R.Ambedkar
2.      The Constitution of India – Wikipedia Page
3.      86th Amendment – The Constitution of India
4.      The Constitution of India – Wikipedia page
5.      ibid
6.      ibid
7.      86th Amendment – 2002 – Constitution of India
8.      The All Global Monitoring Report ( GMR)
9.      Teach for India – NGO online portal
10.  Innovative Solutions To Community Development Initiative -  Online Portal - http://isdnigeria.org/
11.  Ministry for Human Resource Development – Online Portal
12.  The child Labor Act, 1986
13.  Art.24, 45 of the Constitution of India


Opposition Party : Basic Pillar of Democracy


Most Indians speak with great pride as though their country was already a democracy. The foreigners also, when they sit at a dinner table to do diplomatic honor to India, speak of the Great Indian Prime Minister and the Great Indian Democracy.
From this, it is held without waiting to argue that where there is a Republic, there must be democracy. It is also supposed that where there is Parliament which is elected by the people on adult suffrage and the laws are made by the People’s Representatives in Parliament elected after few years, there is democracy. In other words, democracy is understood to be a political instrument and where this political instrument exists, there is democracy. Is there democracy in India or is there no democracy in India? What is the truth? No positive answer can be given unless the confusion caused by equating democracy with Republic and by equating democracy with Parliamentary Government is removed.

According to Dr.B.R.Ambedkar Democracy is quite different from a Republic as well as from Parliamentary Government. He says “The roots of democracy lie not in the form of Government, Parliamentary or otherwise. A democracy is more than a form of Government. It is primarily a mode of associated living. The roots of Democracy are to be searched in the social relationship, in the terms of associated life between the people who form a society.”
From the above definition we can understand that democracy is to be found in social relationship in terms of associated life. India is known for its divers nature. We have thousands of castes, religions, different races and millions of languages. Despite having so many differences and diversified culture, we are considered to be united nation. And more over a strongest developing democracy of the world. 
Here, to make any democratic constitution a successful one, the countrymen must live a harmonious life and loyalty to public ends and mutuality of sympathy and co-operation. The question raises in mind that do we really have the above mentioned qualities in among us ? do the countrymen live a harmonious life without any social, political, economic and religious differences ? from the ages India consists of an innumerable collection of castes which are exclusive in their life and have no common experience to share and have no bond of sympathy. Given this fact it is not necessary to argue the point since we come across the caste hatred and atrocities in our day to life. The existence of the Caste System is a standing denial of the existence of those ideals of society and therefore of democracy.
Several eminent personalities have defined democracy. The dictionary meaning of the democracy is “government by the people in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system”.
Walter Bagehot defined democracy as “Government by discussion”. According to  Mr.Abraham Lincoln, democracy is a government “ of the people, by the people and for the people”.
Democracy is indeed the form of government elected by the people for them. But we have to understand that democracy is a set of ideas and principles about freedom. Dr.B.R.Ambedkar defines democracy in a unique way as thus “Democracy is a form and method of government whereby revolutionary changes in the social life are brought about without bloodshed.”
Among the above said few definitions Dr.Ambedkar’s definitions stands apt. the real test of democracy is to be analyzing the change in social life. Democracy is not just a form of government; it is mode of associated living, an essential attitude of respect and reverence towards our fellow men. But we can see that, in our day to day life, due to the different castes, religions, traditions and various faith each caste tends to dislike others just because they belong to different caste. But the greatest contribution of Indian Constitution is despite the differences, India is still going strong without any internal disbursement unlike our neighboring countries!
Let’s turn towards the main topic i.e. Opposition Party: The Basic Pillar of Democracy! in any democracy the opposition party plays a vital role.  In politics, the opposition comprises one or more political parties that are against the ruling government. Ideally the opposition party goes against the ruling party in any government.
The main role of the opposition party is to check and question the policies made by the ruling party and draw attention on the real causes of the nation and to stop ruling party from over powering people. It has to question the government of the day and hold them accountable to the public. The opposition is equally responsible in upholding the best interests of the people of the country. They have to ensure that the government does not take any steps which might have negative implications on the people of the country.
Basically, the opposition party have to check the excesses of the ruling or dominant party and not to be antagonistic. There are actions of the ruling party which may be beneficial to the masses and oppositions are expected to support thing. They should raise immediate protest and voice against the deemed injustice and wrong motions run by the ruling class in the parliament. The leader of opposition should always bear in mind that they are representing the people of India and fighting for justified demands and defending all the unlawful and unfair practices by the ruling classes.
The opposition party has to highlight the failures of the ruling government so convincingly that the common public gets to know the facts behind the failure and understand that the failures were because of the apathy of the government. In the event of a weak opposition party, the ruling government and its representatives may become complacent and insensitive for duration of their rule. Just have a glance through our history of past 15 parliaments and current one India has seen, we will understand that the strong opposition party is needed to safeguard the rights of the common people and for a strong democracy.
But, unfortunately in India, the ruling class and opposition party have become two sides of the same coin. One loot the country after another and without any morale ! In India, the opposition party is not performing its duty and stands as the People’s Voice. Both ruling and opposition parties have joined hands in sucking blood of common man abruptly and unseemingly.  Corruptions after Corruptions, scams after scams but nothing has turned legally against any of the person who is involved in multi crore scams. The agitations and uproar is only to mislead the masses and divert the attention so that everything is fixed meticulously. And this has resulted in threat to the very basics of Parliamentary Democracy and Constitution as a whole.
After the Opposition Parties, Media is considered to be the Fourth Pillar of the Democracy. The role of media is to highlight the day to day issues and enlight people over all the irregularities of the administrative and political branches of the country. These days media is playing very important role in curbing the crimes and wrong doings. Because of technology, people are being aware of all the national and international issues at their very homes. However, what we see that the media has also became the puppet of strong politicians and political parties. Therefore, expecting any news without any undue influence, pressure and impartial and unbiased news is a matter of yesteryears now. The media neither speaks on the issues nor highlight the problems of the common man. I would dare to say that the fourth pillar of democracy has collapsed under the feet of corrupt politicians.
It is evident that, rational authors, writers, social activists, poets have undertook the social responsibility and portraying the role of opposition party now. They raise voice against injustice from time to time. But then, those so called activists too could not dare to come out of their caste and religious notions. They do speaks on the issues aptly, but rarely seen speaking against the real problem of india ie Caste and Religious inequalities, Gender Discriminations, Communal genocides which happens almost every day at all the parts of India.
The time has come to understand the spirit of Constitution and importance of parliamentary democracy. As I mentioned in the beginning of this article is democracy is a social unity. Every member of the society should feel the pain of others, every citizen should understand the meaning and importance of fraternity and brotherhood. Then only we can think of a strong democracy and can achieve the goals enshrined in the constitution ie , Liberty, Equality, Fraternity and Justice. If we all perform our duties well then I am sure, India will be a superpower in the days to come.

References:
2.      Brainy Quotes
3.      Dr.B.R.Ambedkar speech in the Constituent Assemble on 26th November 1949.
4.      Adv Mahendra Jadhav : Online Blog